All Creative Work Is Derivative (Nina Paley)
Nina Paley's short animation, made entirely from photographs of sculptures at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, arguing that all creative work builds on what came before.
Source Information
- Creator: Nina Paley (photography and animation)
- Music: Todd Michaelsen, “Sita’s String Theory” (a bonus track from the Sita Sings the Blues soundtrack)
- Format: Animated short, 2 min 20 s; the second film in QuestionCopyright.org’s Minute Memes series
- Published: February 2010
- Licence: Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0
- URL: https://archive.org/details/AllCreativeWorkIsDerivative
- Why captured: a compact reminder that nothing starts from nothing. Watching it makes me want to make things.
What it shows (paraphrased)
Paley photographed sculptures in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York and sequenced the photographs so that figures from different times and places seem to move, dance and turn into one another. The film contains no imagery of its own. Every frame is someone else’s work, so the film demonstrates its claim, that all creative work builds on what came before, just by existing.
Context
The Minute Memes were short films QuestionCopyright.org commissioned to argue that copying drives culture rather than stealing from it; the first was Copying Is Not Theft. They’re licensed so that anyone may copy and remix them. Paley came to the subject through her feature film Sita Sings the Blues (2008), whose release was held up by licensing fees for 1920s songs.
Criticism
Commenters, among them the archaeologist Kristina Killgrove, pointed out that the film shows the sculptures without context: where and when each was made is lost. Similar poses across cultures don’t prove that one sculptor copied another, because shared bodies and shared conventions can produce similar results independently. So the film shows creativity growing out of a culture, not one work copying another.
Atomic Notes
- [[All Creative Work Is Derivative]]: the core claim, and why it’s freeing
- [[Memes Spread by Copying With Variation]]: the series name, and culture’s copying made visible
- [[Copyright Protects Expression, Not Ideas]]: the legal line that leaves room for cultural borrowing
- [[The Public Domain Is Raw Material for New Work]]: why Paley could make this film without asking anyone
Source: Internet Archive โ All Creative Work Is Derivative
4 notes link here
- All Creative Work Is Derivative Every creative work is built from earlier work; originality is a new arrangement โฆ
- Copyright Protects Expression, Not Ideas Copyright covers the specific form in which an idea is expressed, never the idea โฆ
- Memes Spread by Copying With Variation A meme is a unit of culture that spreads by imitation; each copy varies a little โฆ
- The Public Domain Is Raw Material for New Work Once a work's copyright expires, anyone can build on it without permission; long โฆ